ok, thanks. understood why he has his own thread...but that doesn't change my stance about his talent and potential.i have expressed my opinions and thoughts in a calm and civilized manner...i'm not a hater, just a skeptic wondering what all the fuss is about. a lot of guys here tag him as the next best bigman of the country, and surround him with a lot of hype and mystique. that already raises a lot of arguments and questions. why did he only win a title when greg was shipped out? why couldn't he tow his team to the pccl title despite being tourney mvp? if he is that good (as what people who praise him say he is) then he should have done those things.
This is a long shot, but would I be justified in saying that you wouldn't want a Charles Barkley thread just because he didn't win any championships?
As nardy said, he's a good topic of discussion. He's had good games against UAAP and NCAA teams, and it was clear that no one could contain him one-on-one. Is it hype? No, those are real, tangible results. I myself had my reservations about him, but started believing he's for real after he dominated the Blue Eagles frontline last year.
Is he the next best big man in the country? Personally, I think Slaughter (getting teammates involved) and Taha (athleticism and defensive timing) are slightly ahead of him. But those three are way ahead of the other players of similar height (6'7" above) right now.