Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Player naturalisations

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Player naturalisations

    Naturalizations over all are pretty much ok for me but this current situation in basketball is simply very stupid.

  • #2
    I am not against neutralizing but there must be a logic to select players who are neutralized. There must be some rules for that

    1. Players who already have European passport cannot be neutralized such as Preldzic, Begic, Mirkovic etc

    2. Other continent players must play at least 3 years in the country where they will play for if they play in another league current season. And they can be neutralized after 1st year.
    IF YOU ARE NOT REAL CANARY, THEN FU

    https://twitter.com/INTEGRAL1907

    REPUBLIC of FENERBAHÇE 2017-18

    Sloukas, B Dixon, Colom, R.Neto
    Wanamaker, Guduric, MeMa, Djedovic, Causeur
    Datome, Bertans, Nunnaly, Hanga, Lojeski, Ponitka, Ulanovas
    Melli, Kalinic, Shengelia, Bjelica, Teletovic
    Vesely, A.Düverioğlu, Marjanovic, Dubljevic, J Hamilton, Lauvergne, Jokic, Ante Zizic

    Comment


    • #3
      Originally posted by INTEGRAL View Post
      I am not against neutralizing but there must be a logic to select players who are neutralized. There must be some rules for that

      1. Players who already have European passport cannot be neutralized such as Preldzic, Begic, Mirkovic etc

      2. Other continent players must play at least 3 years in the country where they will play for if they play in another league current season. And they can be neutralized after 1st year.
      No one needs neutralized players

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by Mindozas View Post
        No one needs neutralized players
        Haha why not?

        Enemy down
        IF YOU ARE NOT REAL CANARY, THEN FU

        https://twitter.com/INTEGRAL1907

        REPUBLIC of FENERBAHÇE 2017-18

        Sloukas, B Dixon, Colom, R.Neto
        Wanamaker, Guduric, MeMa, Djedovic, Causeur
        Datome, Bertans, Nunnaly, Hanga, Lojeski, Ponitka, Ulanovas
        Melli, Kalinic, Shengelia, Bjelica, Teletovic
        Vesely, A.Düverioğlu, Marjanovic, Dubljevic, J Hamilton, Lauvergne, Jokic, Ante Zizic

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Joško Poljak Fan View Post
          The list of absences is getting longer by the day

          Goran Dragič 99% won't play
          Edo Murič, injured his shoulder
          Domen and Erazem Lorbek, first one chronical injuries, second one reportedly hasn't yet started practicing
          Mirza Begič - needs a summer off with his knees


          Players invited to the NT, 4 will join from the B NT
          Jaka Blažič
          Jure Balažič
          Žiga Dimec
          Zoran Dragič
          Bryant Dunston *
          Nebojša Joksimovič
          Jaka Klobučar
          Alen Omič *
          Klemen Prepelič
          Uroš Slokar
          Gašper Vidmar

          with the 4-5 players mentioned above missing that's a severely limited roster.
          Slovenia are going easy way too with american ? Lithuania and Serbs basically only 2 left countries which still goes playing their own boys...Most likely these 2 countries has biggest pride and tradicion of their basketball history...I read what teodocis said about naturalised players,its like 80% lithuanians think too.

          Heck one day we should do same pay money to nba PG and with our depth and big frontcouart definetely would be in favorite list before champ.But the problem is that the "taste of wins" woudnt be the same...
          Last edited by Shawshank; 06-16-2015, 12:09 PM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Shawshank View Post
            But the problem is that the "taste of wins" woudnt be the same...
            Amen. In Finland if you marry a Finn, speak proper finnish (test is very hard and our language is extremely hard) and live at least 3 years in Finland it is possible to be Finn. If you don't marry a Finn it's even two times harder. It is possible that you come from somewhere like 1 year old and you get passport when you are 18. And if you get passport you have to go to army. You have to.

            If every countries would have such a rules there would not be problem at all.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Shawshank View Post
              Most likely these 2 countries has biggest pride and tradicion of their basketball history...I read what teodocis said about naturalised players,its like 80% lithuanians think too.
              .
              serbian women basketball team currently playing at EC includes a player called Danielle Page from Colorado, USA. At the last EC serbian women team was fourth, then playing without a foreign player.
              who knows what the future will bring...
              But I agree, majority of the fans are against that, the only thing is we are not the ones who decide on that. Unfortunately.
              "Heja, heja Cibosi, hrabri kao vukovi,

              heja, heja cibosi, vodite nas k pobjedi. "

              Comment


              • #8
                The Greek Federation has taken a stand against naturalisations for years, although we could have used a big man such as Mike Batiste, who lived in the country for about 10 years and had every right to citizenship. They say that such a move would be bad for team chemistry, and unfair to the young Greek guys who aspire to play for the NT. That said, we have no problem with using Greek-Americans who do not even speak the language, such as Koufos and Calathes. And now we have Giannis Antetokounmpo, who is the son of an imiigrant family, but was born and raised and lived his whole life in Greece. It's a complicated situation, and there are no "rights" or "wrongs". I can certainly tell you that everyone here was very sarcastic and bitter when we lost to a FYROM team led by an American who barely knew where Skopje was back in 2009. But we laughed our heads off with JR Holden's winner for Russia two years earlier. At least Holden used to live and work in Moscow for years.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by Svoura View Post
                  The Greek Federation has taken a stand against naturalisations for years, although we could have used a big man such as Mike Batiste, who lived in the country for about 10 years and had every right to citizenship. They say that such a move would be bad for team chemistry, and unfair to the young Greek guys who aspire to play for the NT. That said, we have no problem with using Greek-Americans who do not even speak the language, such as Koufos and Calathes. And now we have Giannis Antetokounmpo, who is the son of an imiigrant family, but was born and raised and lived his whole life in Greece. It's a complicated situation, and there are no "rights" or "wrongs".
                  Antetokounmpo was born and raised in Greece, of course he should play for his country Greece. It's beyond me why he's even in this conversation.

                  Batiste playing for Greece would have made a lot more sense than Koufos, at least Batiste lived in Greece and played there for years. Once Batiste becomes a Greek citizen, he's certainly more of a Greek basketball player than Koufos, no matter which way you slice it.

                  FIBA should adopt IIHF rules, where a player like Koufos would only be eligible for Greece after 2 years in the Greek league. The idea that someone qualifies to a national team solely based on his "heritage" is ludicrous.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    You have a point, but plase keep in mind that Koufos has played for the Greek national teams (from U18 to Men's) around 50 times,on three separate summers. Also, both his parents are 100% Greek. It's not an empty heritage.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Originally posted by Svoura View Post
                      You have a point, but plase keep in mind that Koufos has played for the Greek national teams (from U18 to Men's) around 50 times,on three separate summers. Also, both his parents are 100% Greek. It's not an empty heritage.
                      Yes he played for Greek national teams, but shouldn't have been allowed to. He should have had to play in the Greek league first to even become eligible.

                      And his parents could be from Mars for all I care, it shouldn't make any difference either way.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        I am totally against it , its ruining the purpose of the national team competitions . But I must to admit , Danielle Page really have grown on me , she is basically volunteer in our women national basketball team, she doesn't have any monetary contract with our basketball federation, she even learned to sing our national anthem , because she wanted to, she completed the entire preparations before women Eurobasket , with our national team, and she played her butt off and in the process helped us won the women eurobasket for the first time in our basketball history , she's a very special person. But hopefully she's the first and last naturalize player for Serbia.
                        UZEO SI TROFEJ MACVANE MACVANE MACVANE!!!

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Originally posted by Srle View Post
                          I am totally against it , its ruining the purpose of the national team competitions . But I must to admit , Danielle Page really have grown on me , she is basically volunteer in our women national basketball team, she doesn't have any monetary contract with our basketball federation, she even learned to sing our national anthem , because she wanted to, she completed the entire preparations before women Eurobasket , with our national team, and she played her butt off and in the process helped us won the women eurobasket for the first time in our basketball history , she's a very special person. But hopefully she's the first and last naturalize player for Serbia.
                          this ^ another thing is i dont care about women bball and i dont follow it i dont watch it so its not important for me,but the moment we naturalize player(i mean some american player that never had anything to do with Serbia) i will not care for Serbian men NT,i mean i alredy have one club that i like and im its fan,it is Red Star
                          Republic of CRVENA ZVEZDA

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Originally posted by Srle View Post
                            I am totally against it , its ruining the purpose of the national team competitions . But I must to admit , Danielle Page really have grown on me , she is basically volunteer in our women national basketball team, she doesn't have any monetary contract with our basketball federation, she even learned to sing our national anthem , because she wanted to, she completed the entire preparations before women Eurobasket , with our national team, and she played her butt off and in the process helped us won the women eurobasket for the first time in our basketball history , she's a very special person. But hopefully she's the first and last naturalize player for Serbia.
                            it's none of my business but I suspect these are all excuses needed to convince oneself. These stories are very similar to what we have heard about McCalebb (or about some others).
                            5 out 6 scientists say Russian roulette is safe.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Originally posted by Srle View Post
                              I am totally against it , its ruining the purpose of the national team competitions . But I must to admit , Danielle Page really have grown on me , she is basically volunteer in our women national basketball team, she doesn't have any monetary contract with our basketball federation, she even learned to sing our national anthem , because she wanted to, she completed the entire preparations before women Eurobasket , with our national team, and she played her butt off and in the process helped us won the women eurobasket for the first time in our basketball history , she's a very special person. But hopefully she's the first and last naturalize player for Serbia.
                              I vehemently oppose this view. Koufos participation in the Greek NT is 100% legit. The man is Greek. Simple as that. This man speaks fluently Greek and is very attached to the Greek American community. Just this summer he got married to a Greek-American woman. He once went to school carrying the Greek flag when Greece eliminated the USA at the WC in 2006. Calathes is more Americanized, but still. He is a Greek American. Surely, both this players could have chosen to play for the USA if they had the potential to do that. That would have been fair enough, but they choose to represent Greece given their Greek heritage. This sounds very reasonable to me.

                              In my opinion the Greek federation has kept its stand. Any player of Greek origin can play for Greece if he desire to do so. This has been their policy since the 60s and it has brought a lot of success for Greek basketball.
                              As for players such as Antetokoumpo. Not even worth discussing as they are born and raised in Greece. So if they choose to represent Greece than it goes without saying that they have every right to do so.

                              I am actually against the naturalization of players who are neither born, raised, nor have any ethnic connection to that country. Playing pro-basketball in that country for a few years does not suffice. So no. Mike Batiste playing for Greece, as much as I like him, would not have been right. He made the offer at times, but the Greek federation rightfully declined the offer.
                              Last edited by Victorious; 07-15-2015, 11:38 PM.
                              PAO EUROPEAN CHAMPION 1996 - 2000 - 2002 - 2007 - 2009 - 2011 - 2024

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X

                              Debug Information