UAAP season 87

[Tamunggoy]

Again the number of years he played doesnt matter. He is playing as a graduate transfer which is allowed in the uaap. If you have gripes with it talk to your uaap reps about it.

so if a guy played 5 years in NCAA here, he can be allowed to play in the UAAP without residency? Troy Rike played 4 years kn Wake Forest.

[gospursgo]

so if a guy played 5 years in NCAA here, he can be allowed to play in the UAAP without residency? Troy Rike played 4 years kn Wake Forest.

In theory yes but as ive already said to sir tuck, no one has ever done it because by the time ncaa guys finishes their playing years they'll be overaged in the uaap.

[Tamunggoy]

Yes assuming they're not yet overaged. Most of the time ncaa graduates maximize their playing year meaning they usually graduate or finish their 5 playing year by the time they 25 or turning 26 already. Meaning they will be overaged in the uaap

For context Uaap also gave an extra year for all athletes in all sports because of the pandemic its not only us ncaa that did it.

Are sure that UAAP gave an extra year during Covid? It was only given to “super seniors” who failed to play in 2nd season sports in 2020 like volleyball

[gospursgo]

Are sure that UAAP gave an extra year during Covid? It was only given to “super seniors” who failed to play in 2nd season sports in 2020 like volleyball

Even if they gave the extra year or not it doesnt affect qmb's status in the uaap as a graduate transfer.

[Tamunggoy]

Even if they gave the extra year or not it doesnt affect qmb's status in the uaap as a graduate transfer.

Are you admitting that you were wrong in your statement that “UAAP gave an extra year because of Covid”?

[gospursgo]

Are you admitting that you were wrong in your statement that “UAAP gave an extra year because of Covid”?

What are you trying to prove ba? Sige for your sake im wrong, you happy? At the end of the day no matter how much you complain here, it womt change the fact qmb will play for UP next season.

[Tamunggoy]

What are you trying to prove ba? Sige for your sake im wrong, you happy? At the end of the day no matter how much you complain here, it womt change the fact qmb will play for UP next season.

Can you give an example of a
player who played 5 years in college and was allowed to
play in UAAP?

[gospursgo]

Can you give an example of a
player who played 5 years in college and was allowed to
play in UAAP?

Give me the rule first that forbids players who played 5 years in college, in the uaap. Me, im just basing it on grad transfer rules.

[scuderia01ph]

Isn’t that the five playing seasons in 7 years rule. Regardless if undergrad, graduate, transfer, local, foreign etc.

Maybe UP is banking on loopholes with pandemic rules.

https://www.spin.ph/life/guide/has-uaap-rule-loophole-opened-floodgates-for-one-and-done-players-a2437-20190827

[gospursgo]

Isn’t that the five playing seasons in 7 years rule. Regardless if undergrad, graduate, transfer, local, foreign etc.

Maybe UP is banking on loopholes with pandemic rules.

https://www.spin.ph/life/guide/has-u...a2437-20190827

Yup there could be loophole because of the pandemic, even by applying the 5 by 7 rule. Qmb in theory chould still have 1 year left. Why? Because us ncaa cancelled the 20-21 season as it was underway meaning that shouldnt count as a playing year. So yes he played for 5 years, but only 4 of those seasons were actually completed. This is the reason the us ncaa extended the all student athletes affected with another year of eligibility.

Biggest question is how does the uaap board see it. Will they count the abandoned season as a playing year or not? My guess they'll treat it similar to the past graduate transfers like rike and meeker. Not to mention if there were rumblings or protests from other team's officials we shouldve already heard it now.

[scuderia01ph]

Interesting case. UAAP pandemic season didn’t count towards playing years I believe for the Volleyball players as they only played about 2 games. Not sure for other sports and how 1st/2nd semester schedule counts.

Looks like QMB played 19 games (typical season 36 games) in 2020-2021 based on profile in link below. Is half season counted in playing years? I’m thinking generally accepted no, which makes him just have 4 playing years and eligible as one and done.

https://www.espn.com/mens-college-basketball/player/_/id/4397691/quentin-millora-brown

[gospursgo]

Interesting case. UAAP pandemic season didn’t count towards playing years I believe for the Volleyball players as they only played about 2 games. Not sure for other sports and how 1st/2nd semester schedule counts.

Looks like QMB played 19 games (typical season 36 games) in 2020-2021 based on profile in link below. Is half season counted in playing years? I’m thinking generally accepted no, which makes him just have 4 playing years and eligible as one and done.

https://www.espn.com/mens-college-ba...-millora-brown

Same sentiments. Thats why those affected by the pandemic were also given another year of eligibility by the uaap. They also extended the age limit from 25 to 27 to accomodate it.

Siguro my biggest take away from all this.......UP has one heck of an adviser finding loopholes like this lol hahaha, i dont even wanna deep dive on the cagulangan issue but man they keep on finding ways on how to exploit the loophole in the rulebook.

And that QMB must really love studying. That one year with citadel was also a post grad year. So this stint with UP will give him his second post graduate degree lol.

[Petertheanteater]

Here in the US, the 20-21 season was deemed as the covid bonus year. Anyone who played that season (regardless of games played) didnt have it count against their eligibility years. So technically QMB only played 4 years of his eligibility, and UAAP/NCAA Philippines allows 5 thus giving him an extra one. I don’t even know why there is an argument here.

COVID messed alot of things up and created anomalies like this.

[Tuck]

i think the point of contention is playing years not the masters. UAAP counts playing years at a cap of 5 . AFAIK if you play 5 years in the Phil Ncaa you cant play in the uaap anymore but why does the us ncaa differ.

They shut down the season with like a month left anyway .Thats still a playing year.

Kwetyute Graduated beda with an age young enough to play UAAP but he couldnt cause if playing yrs.

[The_Big_Cat]

i think the point of contention is playing years not the masters. UAAP counts playing years at a cap of 5 . AFAIK if you play 5 years in the Phil Ncaa you cant play in the uaap anymore but why does the us ncaa differ.

They shut down the season with like a month left anyway .Thats still a playing year.

Kwetyute Graduated beda with an age young enough to play UAAP but he couldnt cause if playing yrs.

Kwekuteye played only 4 years. He skipped his final year in Season 99.