Originally posted by robert0326
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Philippine PBA Trades, Releases, Sign-ups, Rumours (vol. III)
Collapse
This is a sticky topic.
X
X
-
-
Originally posted by robert0326Wow!!!! They revise the trade and it will be Cabagnot going to Dyip for Enciso then Adams will go to Ginebra for Tolentino plus future 1st round pick of Ginebra (probably 2021/Season 47).. My opinion is Cabagnot - Enciso is already a fair trade while Adams for Tolentino + future 1st round pick is also a fair trade especially if the 1st Round Pick will be next draft due to possibly loaded batch of Fil-foreigners coming and Ginebra's pick will probably in mid 1st round due to poor PHL cup showing even their upcoming Gov's cup performance will be better for them... But still a farming move for Dyip, We all know their intentions even this trade are fair enough...
https://tiebreakertimes.com.ph/tbt/s...ginebra/224656Originally posted by thatweirdguy View PostWell they just traded their most promising player for Tolentino who's possibly going to be shipped out to another SMC team and a first round pick who will be going back to an SMC team if he pans out. Enciso for Cabagnot looks like a fair trade until you asked why they would trade for Cabagnot who's being paid more and is nearing retirement. Its a move that only benefits SMB.
But, I dunno. thatweirdguy does have a point. Baka maging vicious cycle of trades. I dunno how to resolve this. The team getting the better player usually sacrifices more assets. SMB has to give up a 1st and a 2nd. Ginebra on the other hand has to give up at least two firsts for the trade to be justifiable. Pero, if Arvin plays well with TerraFirma, then they kinda win too, since he's also a promising player, after which he might be shipped to an SMC team. Pero, I haven't seen a trade where teams give up a young high-upside asset for another asset player + a 1st round pick.
As for Cabagnot, oo nga, why the hell would you take an aging player?
Well, Ginebra resolves their wing problem with Adams, and SMB gets younger in the guard position. Enciso's a tough man-to-man defender too.
Comment
-
Originally posted by robert0326Well, most of players coming from SMC moving to their farm teams are still payed by SMC umbrella.. just ask Roger Yap and Jondan Salvador... hehehehehehehehe!!!
Comment
-
Originally posted by IPC View PostHoly hell, I didn't expect Ginebra to make a move for Adams. But hell, I'd be lying if I said I'm not excited for him. Sana lang hindi mabangko.
But, I dunno. thatweirdguy does have a point. Baka maging vicious cycle of trades. I dunno how to resolve this. The team getting the better player usually sacrifices more assets. SMB has to give up a 1st and a 2nd. Ginebra on the other hand has to give up at least two firsts for the trade to be justifiable. Pero, if Arvin plays well with TerraFirma, then they kinda win too, since he's also a promising player, after which he might be shipped to an SMC team. Pero, I haven't seen a trade where teams give up a young high-upside asset for another asset player + a 1st round pick.
As for Cabagnot, oo nga, why the hell would you take an aging player?
Well, Ginebra resolves their wing problem with Adams, and SMB gets younger in the guard position. Enciso's a tough man-to-man defender too.
Comment
-
Originally posted by thatweirdguy View PostYes everyone got to address their weaknesses except Terrafirma. As for Arvin he'll likely be told to bulk up and post up more lol
But to be fair to Cardel, he hasn't treated Adams like a traditional stretch 4 and more of a wing these days.
Comment
-
Originally posted by thatweirdguy View PostWho can they send out though? They wouldn't trade anyone of value for Perez. I don't think they'll part with Pessumal for someone who's possibly a worse player than Jaymar.
Ganyan na ganyan ang sinabi ni Leo Austria during the CJ Perez trade. Kaya yung mga players na ipinamigay ng SMB for Perez eh mga basura.
Kagaguhan!"A king may move a man, a father may claim a son, but that man can also move himself, and only then does that man truly begin his own game. Remember that howsoever you are played or by whom, your soul is in your keeping alone, even though those who presume to play you be kings or men of power, when you stand before God, you cannot say, 'But I was told by others to do thus,' or that virtue was not convenient at the time. This will not suffice." - King Baldwin IV
Comment
-
Originally posted by robert0326Wow!!!! They revise the trade and it will be Cabagnot going to Dyip for Enciso then Adams will go to Ginebra for Tolentino plus future 1st round pick of Ginebra (probably 2021/Season 47).. My opinion is Cabagnot - Enciso is already a fair trade while Adams for Tolentino + future 1st round pick is also a fair trade especially if the 1st Round Pick will be next draft due to possibly loaded batch of Fil-foreigners coming and Ginebra's pick will probably in mid 1st round due to poor PHL cup showing even their upcoming Gov's cup performance will be better for them... But still a farming move for Dyip, We all know their intentions even this trade are fair enough...
https://tiebreakertimes.com.ph/tbt/s...ginebra/224656
Honestly, I see this as a "fair" trade. I mean for trades involving SMC teams, fair na ito."A king may move a man, a father may claim a son, but that man can also move himself, and only then does that man truly begin his own game. Remember that howsoever you are played or by whom, your soul is in your keeping alone, even though those who presume to play you be kings or men of power, when you stand before God, you cannot say, 'But I was told by others to do thus,' or that virtue was not convenient at the time. This will not suffice." - King Baldwin IV
Comment
-
Adams for Tolentino + pick is basically 2 for 1... but for the other way around. We all know the pick Ginebra is shipping out is gonna be a future SMC player. As for another trade. It's lopsided. Think about it. Even if you argue Alex is better than Enciso but what are they going to gain from a 38 year old soon to be retired Alex Cabagnot vs another PG on his prime? Are they gunning for a title? Kaya they want a "better" talent even just for 1 year?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Jupitersa View PostAdams for Tolentino + pick is basically 2 for 1... but for the other way around. We all know the pick Ginebra is shipping out is gonna be a future SMC player. As for another trade. It's lopsided. Think about it. Even if you argue Alex is better than Enciso but what are they going to gain from a 38 year old soon to be retired Alex Cabagnot vs another PG on his prime? Are they gunning for a title? Kaya they want a "better" talent even just for 1 year?
Comment
-
Originally posted by IPC View PostYeah, TerraFirma should at least be gunning for the playoffs. They have the talent, e, even after the trades. I mean, after Adams, they still have Munzon, Tiongson, Laput, and decent role players like Ramos, Cahilig, MGR, Camson.
Comment
-
Originally posted by robert0326Wow!!!! They revise the trade and it will be Cabagnot going to Dyip for Enciso then Adams will go to Ginebra for Tolentino plus future 1st round pick of Ginebra (probably 2021/Season 47).. My opinion is Cabagnot - Enciso is already a fair trade while Adams for Tolentino + future 1st round pick is also a fair trade especially if the 1st Round Pick will be next draft due to possibly loaded batch of Fil-foreigners coming and Ginebra's pick will probably in mid 1st round due to poor PHL cup showing even their upcoming Gov's cup performance will be better for them... But still a farming move for Dyip, We all know their intentions even this trade are fair enough...
https://tiebreakertimes.com.ph/tbt/s...ginebra/224656Never look too far ahead. You might stumble on a block right in front of you.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Jupitersa View PostAdams for Tolentino + pick is basically 2 for 1... but for the other way around. We all know the pick Ginebra is shipping out is gonna be a future SMC player. As for another trade. It's lopsided. Think about it. Even if you argue Alex is better than Enciso but what are they going to gain from a 38 year old soon to be retired Alex Cabagnot vs another PG on his prime? Are they gunning for a title? Kaya they want a "better" talent even just for 1 year?Never look too far ahead. You might stumble on a block right in front of you.
Comment
-
Originally posted by robert0326He's not the 1st pick.. 2nd pick can be traded right away.. as early as next season eh nasa SMB na yan.. Baka nga middle of 2nd conference this season he will be traded to SMB eh... I say Lassiter + Sena + Gamalinda for Malonzo trade incoming...
Comment
-
Originally posted by NOiNU View PostHaha you beat me to it. But yeah, these kind of trades are made by teams on WIN NOW mode. Like Paul to Phoenix, for instance.
Terrafirma has no incentives to win knowing that the next draft is probably going to be stacked.
Comment
Comment