wardjdim said:
The ref whistled a non-existing penalty in the 5th or so min. of the game.
Too categorical, I think. There's been a lot of discussion about it, I guess no need to provide arguments anymore. Malouda broke through two Italian defenders, Materazzi tried to avoid contact, but tripped Malouda's right ankle - a very slight touch. A dive? I'm not sure at that speed. Accidental tripping worthy of a penalty? Why not? Sometimes the ref will call it, sometimes he won't ...
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmgo4l.jpg
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmgpdt.jpg
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmgrgx.jpg
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmgxkw.jpg
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmgyuu.jpg
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmh11i.jpg
http://i6.tinypic.com/1zmh21g.jpg
wardjdim said:
If you had watched Italy before the final, you ould know that they start dominating the rhythm after the 15th minute... Instead, they unfairly had to start running and chasing to tie it. Indeed Italy was better in the 1st half and only in the 2nd, when they couldn't run anymore, they started playing defense.
OK, that might be correct from the tactical point of view. But kinda hard to buy ... "they conceded the first goal, so they had to press to equalise ... when they equalised, they had no more forces to run" ... You can't ask to always control the tempo and make the opponent come from behind. The same France got hit by Spain, but managed to come back and even more.
wardjdim said:
I didnt see anything dirty here. The goal of Materazzi was clearly not a foul
Well, not an outrageous foul, but sometimes such holding by a shoulder will get whistled, sometimes not. This time Materazzi got lucky, on another occasion near that time ge got whistled for a similar holding.
Overall - Italy did great to equalise, they owned the first half after the Zidane's penalty. Not easy to break through the French defence, of course - but they found a very weak spot - dead-ball situations (corners, free kicks), where the French ... With Pirlo's great delivery, it was coming sooner or later, it seemed.
Compared to the semi-final versus Germany, where the Italians had very nice moments of passing and combinations, this time they were far from it (probably French defence?) ... I remember one magic moment in the 1st half (Gattuso inbounding the ball from the sideline on the right, some passwork between him and Totti, and Toni is released before Barthez - only a last-moment tackle by Thuram clears the danger ... that was really magestic ... ) ... otherwise, the Italians didn't manage to do a lot of that. (Not that fluent passwork is so necessary to win games).
The draw was a fair result, IMO. At the end, the French were more active and creative, but simply not enough to break down the tenacious Italians. Gattuso, Cannavro - not easy to beat those tough guys ... at the end, the penalty shoot-out, and after so many years - finally some luck smiled to Italy. The same Trezeguet, who killed them in 2000, smashes against the crossbar - boom!
The impression of the Italian team is mixed for me. Some fantastic football under Lippi - you gotta love the game versus Ghana (and we probably didn't know at that time how good Ghana) ... A nice semi-final versus Germany (one of those 0-0 games, which are exciting) ... On the other hand, some long stretches "old same Italy" - conservative, defensive, ultra-cautious ... But a welcome change anyway, IMHO.