M
Yes Caidic has said it many times he’s a 2 (shooting guard). In the RP teams, Lagerlite (PABL) and NCC I’ve seen him play he’s mostly a shooting guard. When Allan and Samboy are on the court together, Samboy’s the 3 and Allan is still the 2.
He maybe taller than the usual 2 in the 1980s But he’s still the 2 as you can see how he positions and moves on the court.
Yes, same with what I witnessed. I'll take his word for it (not to mention actual players and coaches agree). If the greatest shooting wing says he's a shooting guard, then that's what I'll consider him.
Guys don't even know that a lot of times, there are players that are playing on the court at the same time who have the same "labeled" position. At any given time there can be 2 PGs, 2 SGs, 2 SFs, etc on the floor at the same time. There's no rule saying you can only have one at a time.
Heck Kai and JMF plays together so what does that make Kai now? Kai's taller so maybe JMF is the PF, but wait JMF is slow so he's the C...it's asinine.
Quite arrogant of U to describe people who doesn't agree with your opinion as an asinine. Do U expect everybody's opinion/view will agree with yours?
I was just saying that during the 90's the Allan Caidic who played for the Philippine team played mostly at the 3 position or the small forward spot & I have proof for that. I never said that Caidic never played as a 2-guard or shooting guard. That's why I said, Caidic probably played mostly as a 2-guard during his stints with the RP-NCC & perhaps during his Great Taste & Presto Tivoli days.
Remember that basketball during the 90's was different from this modern day game where players are more versatile & flexible. At that time the term "position less basketball" did not yet exist.
What I'm thinking is this:
Who would you assign to defend these natural shooting guards in Asia-Oceania basketball?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RNn6GFl16Mc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvAu-y6WGEQ
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-IhbXnsZscE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BWFtAligD6o
Would you put a KQ to defend any of those guys? Or you would put a Dwight Ramos or Chris Newsome (who are both natural 2-guards) instead? I doubt KQ can keep in step with those guys.
Yeah, KQ is laterally slow and realistically not a great perimeter defender but if his hypothetical role in Gilas was as a shooter he’d be making up for it on offense while the coach schemes to hide him on defense. He would be a shooter on offense and probably switch to guarding the weaker offensive guy on defense
On issues like how is he going to guard Arakji, Webster, etc one-on-one? That's not how it works.
Teams always have game plans. When you're against Michael Jordan, not every team will just ask their SG to go ahead and stop MJ. You gameplan for him. It can either be you let him eat but make sure others don't, you "Jordan rules" him, you double-team, defend straight up, etc. Point is, some players require gameplanning.
It's how Kai/JMF didn't get cooked by quicker opposing bigs, there was a game plan.
Cross-matching is also not banned. Newsome is allowed to defend RHJ.
It's not a playground tao-tao game where you're on your own prohibited from using any team strategy.